What’s The Background Of Masterworks?
Masterworks, founded in 2017 by Scott Lynn, is a unique investment platform based in New York City that enables investors to buy shares of high-end art pieces. Lynn, a long-time art collector and entrepreneur saw an opportunity to change how people invest in art and disrupt the traditional art market.
Our research indicates that the Masterworks website offers a service that democratizes access to the fine art market and makes it more accessible to a broader audience. This platform allows investors to buy fractional shares of famous paintings, often worth millions of dollars, by utilizing an innovative business model and leveraging the power of technology.
As investigators of potential scams, we delved into the company’s process of selecting artworks for acquisition. We found that Masterworks utilizes algorithms and data from over 1 million art auctions to pick the best paintings with a solid track record of appreciation. Their strategic approach targets illustrations where the artist has a historical annual return between 9% and 39% source.
During our investigation, we noticed a few key features of this company:
- Masterworks specializes in blue-chip art from established artists that have proven market value.
- Their algorithm-driven selection process uses auction data to identify the best artists and artworks for appreciation potential.
- They operate in a niche art market, focusing on high-value, iconic pieces.
Based on our findings, Masterworks appears to be a legitimate business that aims to revolutionize the art investment market. Thus far, we have not encountered any red flags to suggest the company is a scam..fromString
Why Do People Think Masterworks Is A Scam?
We have observed various reasons why people might perceive Masterworks as a scam. Let’s explore them now.
Firstly, the company has a relatively new presence in the art investment industry, which could raise concerns about its legitimacy. With a limited track record, some investors may hesitate to trust Masterworks with their funds. According to The Ways to Wealth, Masterworks has slightly outpaced the S&P 500 in returns since inception, based on internal appraisals. However, this performance may not be enough to convince all potential investors.
Secondly, some negative reviews have been shared online, such as Reddit posts claiming the platform is dubious. These criticisms may stem from skepticism towards online investment platforms, particularly those dealing with unconventional assets like art.
It’s essential to consider that, as an alternative investment platform, Masterworks allows non-accredited investors to invest in high-end artwork, which may seem too good to be true. Some potential investors could be skeptical of this accessible entry into a market traditionally reserved for wealthy individuals and institutions.
Another factor to consider is the company’s endorsement by third parties. When endorsed by prominent YouTubers whom Masterworks sponsor, there may be doubts about the legitimacy of their claims. Nevertheless, this kind of promotion does not automatically indicate that the company is a scam.
We also noticed that Masterworks isn’t listed on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website, which could lead to further skepticism regarding the company’s credibility.
Taking these factors into account, we can list the following reasons people might perceive Masterworks as a scam:
- Limited track record
- Negative online reviews
- Accessibility to non-accredited investors
- Sponsored endorsements
- Absence from Better Business Bureau listings
However, in our quest to identify a scam, we need to look beyond public opinion and consider factors such as the company’s performance, transparency, and reputation within the industry.
What Masterworks Controversies Or Lawsuits Exist, If Any?
We have not found concrete evidence or notable cases regarding lawsuits or controversies. Although it’s relatively new in the investment industry, Masterworks has established itself as a members-only investment platform that focuses on allowing users to buy and sell fractional investments in iconic pieces of fine art.
However, we must consider the risks associated with this platform. Masterworks might appeal to investors looking for alternative assets, which could provide diversification and potentially more significant returns than traditional stocks. But we should consider some potential risks before jumping in:
- Limited track record: Since it’s a relatively new company, Masterworks has a small track record that can make it difficult for investors to gauge its offerings’ long-term performance and sustainability.
- High fees: Masterworks requires an annual management fee of 1% on investments and a 20% commission on the sale of the artwork. These fees can cut into the overall returns that investors make.
Nonetheless, Masterworks received positive reviews for their excellent investment research on artworks and the contemporary art market and for handling the entire process of finding, purchasing, and storing artwork for their clients, Forbes Advisor.
Considering the information we could gather, it seems that Masterworks is not a scam but a legitimate investment platform in the world of fine arts. Still, we must remain cautious and be aware of the risks associated with this type of investment. Before taking any steps towards investing, individuals need to conduct their research and evaluate their risk tolerance to avoid making uninformed decisions.
What Did We Find In Our Research of Masterworks?
Our research dug deep into various sources to determine if Masterworks is a scam or a legitimate platform. We focused on the information from credible sources like Forbes and user experiences posted on Reddit.
First, we found that Masterworks is a platform that allows investors to buy fractional shares of famous paintings. It opens up the world of fine art investing, typically reserved for high-net-worth individuals, to a broader audience. The platform is well-researched, and the team behind it is experienced in finding, purchasing, and storing masterpieces. This type of investment can diversify one’s portfolio as the artwork appreciates over time.
Then, we checked for user experiences and opinions. We found mixed reviews, with some investors praising the platform as accessible and informative while others expressed skepticism and concern. As with any investment, verifying the information and making a conscious decision based on personal risk tolerance is crucial.
A few things to consider before investing in Masterworks include:
- Masterworks charge a 1.5% annual management fee to purchase, store, and maintain the artwork.
- Fees are also involved in the buying and selling process on the secondary market.
- When an artwork is sold, Masterworks takes a 20% commission.
While some users claim that Masterworks is a dubious investment, others find it an exciting and innovative way to invest in fine art. We suggest potential investors do their due diligence and verify all the necessary information before committing to Masterworks. Evaluate factors such as market trends, historical performance, and how the platform’s fees may affect your return on investment to make an informed decision.
What Is The Company’s Scam Grade for Masterworks?
At first glance, Masterworks may seem like a high-risk investment opportunity in the art world. We understand the skepticism surrounding this platform, so we evaluated its legitimacy.
While analyzing Masterworks’ business practices, we noticed the company maintains transparency in its operations. They provide comprehensive information about the artwork they acquire and the process of buying fractional shares. The platform’s Forbes review also offers a positive outlook on the company, indicating that it is a legitimate investment platform.
There are a few points to consider when evaluating Masterworks for potential scam risks:
- Longevity: the relatively short track record of the company, as mentioned on WallStreetZen, may be a concern for some investors.
- Regulation: Masterworks operates in the unregulated world of fine art, as the Millennial Money Woman pointed out. This lack of oversight can be seen as risky for investors.
- Fees and commissions: The platform charges a 1% annual management fee on investments plus a 20% commission on the sale of the artwork, according to ScamRisk. Although these fees are not unheard of in the art investment, some might find them concerning.
Considering these factors, we give Masterworks a scam grade of B. While it has some inherent risks due to its nature and regulatory environment, we see no evidence of fraudulent activities or mismanagement on its part. We recognize Masterworks as a legitimate platform allowing investors to invest in fractional shares of famous artwork.
Our judgment call is to give Masterworks this letter grade based on the company’s history, fee structure, and performance. While investing in art via Masterworks is not without risks, our research suggests the company operates within legal and ethical boundaries.